High-Yield Savings Calculator - Compare APY Growth (2026)

Project a high-yield savings balance with monthly deposits and compare interest earned against another user-entered APY over the same period.

Updated 2026
Formula verified
No login needed
Mobile friendly
Instant results
Key Summary

With $10,000 and $200 added monthly at 4.25% APY, the balance after 5 years is about $25,630 after $3,630 in interest on $22,000 contributed. The same deposits at the FDIC national average of 0.38% APY reach only $22,304 with $304 in interest, a $3,326 shortfall. According to FDIC data for July 2026 the national average savings rate was 0.38% APY while top high-yield savings accounts paid up to 4.50% APY on August 4, 2026. Enter your initial balance, monthly deposit and APYs below to compare your exact extra interest.

High-Yield Savings Calculator

Enter your details for an instant result

Your details

$
$
%
%
years

Your entries are used only to calculate this result. No account is required. · Share this calculator

How to Use the High-Yield Savings Calculator

1

Enter Your Starting Balance

Enter the amount already in savings, often $0 to $25,000. The calculation applies monthly interest to this balance from day one.

2

Add Your Monthly Deposit

Enter the extra you will add each month, such as $200. Over 5 years $200 monthly equals $12,000 in contributions plus $10,000 initial.

3

Enter Both APYs to Compare

Enter the high-yield APY and a comparison APY, such as 4.25% vs 0.38%. Both yields are converted to the same monthly rate r = (1+APY)^(1/12)-1.

4

Set the Projection Period

Choose 1 to 10 years. The tool compounds monthly for the full term: n = years x 12 months.

5

Review the Side-by-Side Results

Check the final balances, interest earned, extra interest from the higher APY, and the year-by-year table and chart.

The formula
Balance = Initial x (1 + r)^n + PMT x [((1 + r)^n - 1) / r] where r = (1 + APY)^(1/12) - 1
Initial
Balance at the start of the projection before additional deposits.
APY
Annual percentage yield as a decimal (e.g., 4.25% = 0.0425), effective annual return after compounding.
r
Effective monthly rate = (1 + APY)^(1/12) - 1.
n
Total months = years x 12.
PMT
Monthly deposit added at end of each month.
Balance
Projected value after n months at the stated APY.

Projected Balance After 5 Years by APY With $200 Monthly Deposits (2026)

APYInitial $10,000 only$10,000 + $200/mo balanceInterest earnedExtra vs 0.38%
0.38% (national avg)$10,194$22,304$304-
1.50%$10,777$23,223$1,223$919
2.50%$11,326$24,073$2,073$1,769
3.50%$11,906$24,952$2,952$2,648
4.00%$12,217$25,402$3,402$3,098
4.25% (competitive HYSA)$12,313$25,630$3,630$3,326
4.50% (top HYSA)$12,461$25,860$3,860$3,556
Initial $10,000 plus $200 at end of each month for 60 months at fixed APY. Monthly rate r = (1+APY)^(1/12)-1. National average 0.38% APY from FDIC National Rates and Rate Caps, July 2026. Top HYSA up to 4.50% APY August 4, 2026. Source: Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, National Rates and Rate Caps, July 2026 — fdic.gov/resources/resolutions/bank-failures/failed-bank-list/rates.html

How Does APY Turn Monthly Deposits Into Growth?

A high-yield savings account earns interest on both the initial balance and every monthly deposit from the month it arrives. The key conversion is from APY to a monthly rate: r = (1 + APY)^(1/12) - 1. At 4.25% APY, r is about 0.3474% per month, so $10,000 earns about $34.74 in the first month before any deposit. Each $200 deposit then earns its own compounding for the remaining months.

For $10,000 with $200 monthly at 4.25% APY, the balance is about $12,874 after 12 months ($473 interest), $18,985 after 3 years ($1,785 interest), and $25,630 after 5 years ($3,630 interest) (Source: FDIC, fdic.gov). The same $22,000 contributed at the 0.38% national average reaches only $22,304 after 5 years with $304 interest, so the HYSA adds $3,326. Use the Compound Interest Calculator to isolate how much of the growth comes from the initial balance versus ongoing contributions.

High-Yield Savings vs Traditional Savings vs CD: Which Should You Use?

High-yield savings keeps money liquid with a variable APY, a CD locks a fixed APY for a term, and a traditional savings account pays near the national average. The dollar gap scales with time, so the right choice depends on when you need the cash.

Account typeAPY (July 2026)Balance after 5 years ($10k + $200/mo)Interest
Traditional savings0.38%$22,304$304
National avg 12-mo CD1.68%$23,480$1,480
Competitive HYSA4.25%$25,630$3,630
Top 12-mo CD4.50%$25,860$3,860

The HYSA beats the national-average CD by about $2,150 over 5 years and beats a traditional account by $3,326, while keeping funds accessible. A CD beats the HYSA only if you will not touch the money and can capture a top 4.50% fix. Keep 1 to 3 months of expenses liquid in the HYSA and use the CD Calculator to test locked terms for money needed on a known date, or the Emergency Fund Calculator to size the liquid reserve correctly.

How Much Can Fees, Minimums and Variable Rates Cost You?

A $12 monthly fee wipes out most interest on a small balance. At 0.38% APY, $5,000 earns only about $19 per year, so a $12 monthly fee ($144 per year) puts you $125 behind even before inflation. At 4.25% APY, $5,000 earns about $212 per year, so the same fee still costs 68% of the gain (Source: FDIC National Rates, July 2026).

Many high-yield offers are tiered - the advertised 4.25% to 4.50% may require a $5,000 minimum or new-money status, with lower rates below the threshold. Most HYSA rates are variable and track the Federal Reserve, which held the funds target at 3.50% to 3.75% from January through August 2026 and can cut later in 2026 (Source: Federal Reserve H.15, federalreserve.gov). Projections assume the APY stays fixed, so treat them as scenarios and recalculate when your bank changes the rate. Confirm FDIC insurance up to $250,000 per depositor per bank per ownership category (Source: FDIC, fdic.gov).

How Much Extra Will a 1% Higher APY Earn Over Time?

A 1 percentage point improvement compounds into real dollars, especially with ongoing deposits. For $10,000 plus $200 monthly over 5 years, the benchmark curve above shows the payoff clearly.

Moving from 3.25% to 4.25% on that plan raises the 5-year balance from about $24,730 to $25,630, adding $900 in extra interest. Over 10 years the same 1-point gain adds about $3,450 (roughly $41,427 at 3.25% vs $44,877 at 4.25% with the $200 monthly). On a larger $25,000 initial with $500 monthly, the 1-point gain adds about $2,280 over 5 years and about $8,700 over 10 years. The difference between the 0.38% national average and a 4.25% competitive HYSA is already $3,326 over 5 years on $10,000 plus $200 monthly and $10,033 over 10 years (Source: FDIC July 2026 and August 2026 market survey). Even a 0.25% pickup is $42 per year per $10,000 of average balance, so chasing a fee-free 4.25% over a 4.00% offer is worth a transfer when the balance exceeds $8,000.

High-Yield Savings Calculator - Frequently Asked Questions